Savannah housing market historic homes with for sale signs on a tree lined street near the river

Savannah Housing Market: Stubborn Sellers Are Holding It Together

The Savannah housing market has been sluggish for months, and this week the national data finally explained why. Mortgage rates are back at 7.4%. Buyers have thinned out to record lows. By almost every measure, prices should be falling. They are not, and there is one reason: stubborn sellers are single-handedly holding this market together. Here on the coast, there is a second force pulling demand down even further. Chatham County just turned a much tighter short-term rental ordinance into law, and Tybee Island’s new caps arrive January 1. Investors have walked away from both. These are interesting times.

By Julie Gates, Licensed Georgia Broker and Team Leader, Team 912

Savannah housing market historic homes with for sale signs on a tree lined street near the river

Key Takeaways

  • Nationally, about 1.5 million sellers faced only 929,000 buyers in September, the widest gap in Redfin records going back to 2013.
  • Prices are holding only because owners refuse to cut. Owners hold 72% equity in U.S. housing, and nearly half of mortgages carry a rate below 4%.
  • In the Savannah housing market, homes now take about 72 days to sell, up from 59 a year ago, and 40% of listings have cut their price.
  • Chatham County’s new short-term rental ordinance became law on September 25, 2026. It caps non-owner-occupied rentals at about 5% of each zone, limits septic homes to two guests per bedroom, and lets the county suspend or revoke licenses.
  • Tybee Island’s new sector caps take effect January 1, after a moratorium, non-transferable permits, and a lawsuit.
  • With investors on the sidelines in both places, demand is thinner than the national numbers alone suggest.

Stubborn Sellers Are Single-Handedly Holding Up Prices

The Wall Street Journal put it plainly this week. Stubborn sellers are the last thing propping up home prices. Nearly every ingredient for a price decline is already in place, except owners who are desperate to sell.

Consider the math. In September, about 1.5 million Americans were trying to sell, while only 929,000 were actively buying, according to Redfin estimates. That surplus of nearly 600,000 sellers is the largest Redfin has ever recorded. By comparison, in November 2023, the last time rates were this high, sellers outnumbered buyers by only about 100,000.

Meanwhile, the median U.S. home price reached $417,500 in September. That is about 8% higher than in November 2023. As a result, fewer people qualify for a loan, and the number of buyers has fallen about 11% since late 2023.

Why sellers can afford to hold the line

Normally, that kind of imbalance would push prices down. This time, it has not. There are three reasons.

  • Equity is enormous. Owners hold 72% of the value of U.S. housing, compared with 55% right before the 2008 crash.
  • Cheap debt is still everywhere. Nearly half of outstanding mortgages carry a rate below 4%.
  • Jobs are steady. Delinquencies on conventional loans remain low, so very few owners are forced to sell.

So instead of cutting, sellers walk away. In September, 6.1% of sellers pulled their homes off the market after failing to get an acceptable offer. Others rent the house out. Price cuts are happening, but at the margins. In the four weeks through September 20, about one in five sellers lowered their asking price, and nearly half offered concessions such as closing costs or repair credits.

Buyers have left. Sellers have not blinked. That standoff is the only thing keeping prices where they are.

What the Savannah Housing Market Looks Like Right Now

Locally, the Savannah housing market shows the same standoff. Here is the latest from Redfin’s Savannah data and Tybee Island data.

MeasureCity of SavannahTybee Island
Median sale price$331,603 (down 3.1% year over year)$612,208 (up 11.3% year over year)
Median days on market72 (59 a year ago)120 (119 a year ago)
Homes sold in the latest month616 (up 8.3%)33 (down from 36)
Sale-to-list price96.8%96.2%
Listings with a price drop40.1%35.7%
Redfin Compete Score (0–100)36, somewhat competitive11, not very competitive

Savannah figures cover the three months ending August 2026. Tybee Island figures cover the three months ending September 2026. Source: Redfin.

Prices in Savannah are off only about 3%, even though homes are sitting nearly two weeks longer than last year. That is what stubborn sellers look like in the data. On Tybee, the picture is even starker. With only 33 sales in a month, one or two large oceanfront closings can push the median up. The more telling numbers are 120 days on market and a Compete Score of 11.

Chatham County’s New Short-Term Rental Law

Chatham County first adopted its short-term vacation rental ordinance in 2021. It applies only to unincorporated areas, such as Wilmington Island, Talahi Island, Georgetown, and the islands east of Savannah. It does not cover the City of Savannah, Pooler, or Tybee Island, but it reaches some of the most desirable waterfront pockets of the greater Savannah housing market.

This year the county got serious. On July 10, 2026, commissioners froze new short-term rental applications with a 120-day moratorium. Then, on September 25, 2026, they unanimously approved a much tighter ordinance. It is now law. Here is what changed.

  • A cap on licenses. Unincorporated Chatham is now divided into zones based on the county police response neighborhoods. Non-owner-occupied short-term rentals are capped at about 5% of each zone. Homestead properties are not counted against the cap.
  • Grandfathering, with limits. Licenses and applications filed before September 25 are generally exempt from the cap. A buyer without an existing license is competing for whatever room is left in that zone.
  • Lower occupancy on septic. Homes on a septic system are limited to two guests per bedroom, per the Chatham County Health Department, and every rental carries an occupancy cap tied to fire code.
  • Parking plans. Owners must submit a parking plan with their application and update it every year. As presented to commissioners, the standard is one off-street space per bedroom.
  • Posted rules and real contacts. Each rental must post its license, two points of contact, an emergency contact, parking rules, occupancy limits, and noise restrictions.
  • Suspension and revocation. The county can now suspend or revoke a license for repeated violations. It is adding enforcement staff, working directly with Chatham County Police, and building a public map where residents can see licensed rentals and file complaints.
  • HOA rules with teeth. Homeowners associations now have the full backing of county code enforcement for their own neighborhood rental restrictions.

Commission Chairman Chester Ellis called the ordinance “a work in progress,” and the board expects to revisit it. In other words, the rules could tighten further.

What that means for an investor

In practical terms, a short-term rental license in unincorporated Chatham is now a scarce asset. If a zone is already at its cap, a new buyer cannot simply apply and start renting. Before you write an offer, confirm three things: whether the property already holds a license, how close its zone is to the 5% cap, and what the recorded HOA covenants allow.

Tybee Island’s New Caps Take Effect January 1

Tybee has been rewriting its rental rulebook for years. New permits in the residential zones were frozen in 2022. Then, in June 2024, the city made rental certificates non-transferable when a property sold. A group of property managers known as the Tybee Alliance challenged that ordinance in court, and the case was heard in January 2026.

In late August, City Council approved amendments that divide the island into sectors with caps on short-term rentals. As proposed, the north and west sectors would be capped at 30% of eligible residential units, and the east and south sectors at 60%. Every rental must designate an emergency contact, with fines for owners who do not respond, and a waiting list governs new permits. The new rules take effect January 1. We covered the transfer provisions in detail in our Tybee Island transfer trap breakdown.

Investors Walked Away, and Demand Got Even Thinner

For years, short-term rental investors were a dependable source of demand in the coastal Savannah housing market. They paid strong prices on Tybee, Wilmington Island, and the unincorporated islands because the projected nightly revenue justified it. Now that buyer has largely disappeared.

Consequently, the buyer pool shrank twice. First, 7% mortgage rates removed many owner-occupants. Second, years of shifting rules on Tybee, followed by a hard cap in unincorporated Chatham, removed many coastal investors. Fewer buyers chasing the same listings means longer days on market and more homes sitting stale.

Yet prices have still not broken. That is the stubborn seller effect at work. Owners with low-rate mortgages and deep equity would rather wait, rent the home out, or pull it off the market than sell at a discount.

What Could Change the Standoff

The Journal raised the obvious question: how long can sellers hold out? Its answer was sobering. A recession that causes job losses would flush out more sellers. Short of that, the best buyers can hope for is that incomes grow faster than home values, a slow grind back to affordability.

However, there is a floor. Rates near 7.4% are not unusual by historical standards. The 30-year fixed rate has averaged about 7.7% since the early 1970s. And with nearly half of mortgages still below 4%, many owners have no reason to sell at all. That low-rate floor did not exist in past downturns.

What This Means for Investors in the Savannah Housing Market

I have been buying in Savannah since 2004, through 2008, COVID, and the short-term rental shakeout of 2024 and 2025. Here is how I am approaching this market.

  1. Do not wait for a crash. With sellers holding firm and equity this deep, a broad price collapse is not the base case. Buy on today’s numbers.
  2. Underwrite to rents that exist under today’s rules. Price a property on its long-term or 30-day-plus rent. Stays of 30 nights or more generally fall outside short-term vacation rental ordinances, though you should confirm the rules for the specific address.
  3. Treat a short-term rental license as part of the asset. In unincorporated Chatham and on Tybee, an existing license can be worth more than the countertops. Verify its status before any offer.
  4. Negotiate terms, not just price. Nearly half of sellers nationally are offering concessions. A rate buydown or a repair credit can matter more than a lower sticker price.
  5. Budget for Chatham County carrying costs. Investment properties do not qualify for Georgia’s homestead exemption, and Chatham County’s effective tax rate runs above the state average.
  6. Keep leverage reasonable. With rates near 7.4%, a deal that only works at maximum loan-to-value is not a deal.

You do not get paid for betting on a rule change or a price crash. You get paid for buying cash flow that works under the rules already on the books.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are home prices not falling if there are so few buyers?

Because sellers are refusing to cut. Owners hold record equity, nearly half of mortgages carry a rate below 4%, and the job market is steady. Rather than sell at a discount, many owners delist or rent the home out, which keeps prices propped up.

Is the Savannah housing market slowing down?

Yes. The Savannah housing market has slowed noticeably. Homes take about 72 days to sell, up from 59 a year ago, roughly 40% of listings have cut their price, and the typical home sells about 3% below list, according to Redfin.

What is in Chatham County’s new short-term rental ordinance?

Approved unanimously on September 25, 2026, it caps non-owner-occupied short-term rentals at about 5% of each zone, limits homes on septic to two guests per bedroom, requires an annual parking plan, allows license suspension or revocation for repeat violations, and gives HOAs county code-enforcement backing. Existing licenses are generally grandfathered.

Does the Chatham County ordinance apply inside Savannah or on Tybee Island?

No. The county ordinance applies to unincorporated Chatham County only. The City of Savannah and Tybee Island each regulate short-term rentals under their own ordinances.

When do Tybee Island’s new short-term rental rules take effect?

The amended ordinance takes effect January 1. It divides the island into sectors with caps on short-term rentals, adds a waiting list for new permits, and requires an emergency contact for every rental.

Why have investors pulled back from Tybee and unincorporated Chatham?

Uncertainty and caps. Tybee froze new residential permits in 2022 and made certificates non-transferable in 2024. Chatham County froze new applications in July and then capped licenses by zone in September. Without a clear path to a license, many short-term rental investors stopped bidding.

Should investors wait for prices to drop?

Waiting for a crash is a risky strategy in this market. Sellers have deep equity and low-rate mortgages, so most can afford to hold. The better approach is to buy on current rents, negotiate concessions, and keep leverage conservative.

Let’s Talk About Your Next Purchase

If you want to buy in this market with clear eyes, join the Team 912 deal list and we will send you investor-grade listings and off-market opportunities that fit what you are looking for. You are also welcome to call us at (912) 600-2893 or start at team912.com. For more on buying in this market, read why the repair bill on an older Savannah home is your leverage and why Berkshire is buying during the slowdown.

About the Author

Julie Gates is a licensed Georgia real estate broker and has been investing in the Savannah, GA market since 2004, through the 2008 downturn, COVID, and the 2024–25 short-term rental consolidation. Her personal portfolio spans single-family, multifamily, commercial, and self-storage assets across roughly 85 doors. She founded Team 912, an all-investor real estate team in Savannah where every member carries their own portfolio, and Sid Was Here, a Savannah property management company. She is a contributor to the BiggerPockets book The 30-Day Stay (2023), a Forbes Business Council member, a Goldman Sachs 10,000 Small Businesses alumna, and the host of the Cashflow Savannah investor meetup and podcast.

Contact: julie@team912.com | (912) 600-2893 | team912.com

Sources

This article is general market commentary based on the author’s experience as an investor and broker. It is not investment, legal, tax, lending, or insurance advice. No return, cash flow, appreciation, financing, or permit outcome is promised or implied. Short-term rental rules described here reflect public reporting as of October 14, 2026; confirm current ordinance text and zone availability with Chatham County or the City of Tybee Island before relying on it. Market data changes frequently. Consult a licensed mortgage professional, attorney, insurance agent, and CPA about your specific situation.

author avatar
Julie Gates
Julie Gates is a real estate investor first, broker second. She has been investing in Savannah, GA since 2004 and has built a 20-year portfolio across self-storage, short-term rentals, long-term rentals, and commercial real estate. Julie is a licensed real estate broker, co-author of The 30-Day Stay (BiggerPockets Publishing, 2023), a Forbes Business Council member, a regular contributor to Easy Street Capital, a Cornell-certified revenue manager, a graduate of Goldman Sachs 10,000 Small Businesses, and an active SubTo member. She founded Team 912 to provide investor-grade representation in the Savannah market, and also owns Sid Was Here, a Savannah property management company built for investors.